CancelCultureIsNotRealE28094AtLeastNotintheWayYouThink_Time.pdf
10/29/21, 2:38 PM Cancel Culture Is Not Real—At Least Not in the Way You Think | Time
https://time.com/5735403/cancel-culture-is-not-real/ 1/6
Cancel Culture Is Not Real—At Least Not in the WayPeople Think
Illustration by Taylor Callery for TIME
BUILD A BETTER FUTURELIMITED TIME OFFER 1 YEAR FOR $15
SALE ENDS 11/7
SUBSCRIBE NOW
READ NEXT
Post-Dancing with the Stars, Karamo Brown Continues to Support His New 'Friend' Sean
Spicer
10/29/21, 2:38 PM Cancel Culture Is Not Real—At Least Not in the Way You Think | Time
https://time.com/5735403/cancel-culture-is-not-real/ 2/6
IDEASBY SARAH HAGI NOVEMBER 21, 2019 6:43 AM EST
Hagi is a writer based in Toronto
“Has cancel culture gone too far?” The question felt impossible to ignore this
year. Google it and you’ll see pages of op-eds, often concluding, yes, it has
gone too far, and the Internet mob is out of control.
Cancel culture became so central to the discourse in 2019 that even President
Obama weighed in. The idea is that if you do something that others deem
problematic, you automatically lose all your currency. Your voice is silenced.
You’re done. Those who condemn cancel culture usually imply that it’s unfair
and indiscriminate.
The problem with this perspective is cancel culture isn’t real, at least not in the
way people believe it is. Instead, it’s turned into a catch-all for when people in
power face consequences for their actions or receive any type of criticism,
something that they’re not used to.
BUILD A BETTER FUTURELIMITED TIME OFFER 1 YEAR FOR $15
SALE ENDS 11/7
SUBSCRIBE NOW
READ NEXT
Post-Dancing with the Stars, Karamo Brown Continues to Support His New 'Friend' Sean
Spicer
NEXT UP: EDITOR'S PICK
America Needs to Get Back to Facts
10/29/21, 2:38 PM Cancel Culture Is Not Real—At Least Not in the Way You Think | Time
https://time.com/5735403/cancel-culture-is-not-real/ 3/6
I’m a black, Muslim woman, and because of social media, marginalized people
like myself can express ourselves in a way that was not possible before. That
means racist, sexist, and bigoted behavior or remarks don’t fly like they used
to. This applies to not only wealthy people or industry leaders but anyone
whose privilege has historically shielded them from public scrutiny. Because
they can’t handle this cultural shift, they rely on phrases like “cancel culture”
to delegitimize the criticism.
Since the #MeToo hashtag went viral in 2017, more women have spoken out
about their experiences with sexual harassment and assault. While many
people have applauded this movement, some men now say they fear even
casual interactions with women will get them canceled.
PAID PARTNER CONTENT
Era of driverless vehicles on theway to realityBY CHINA DAILY
TIME Person of the Year 2017: The Silence Breakers
BUILD A BETTER FUTURELIMITED TIME OFFER 1 YEAR FOR $15
SALE ENDS 11/7
SUBSCRIBE NOW
READ NEXT
Post-Dancing with the Stars, Karamo Brown Continues to Support His New 'Friend' Sean
Spicer
NEXT UP: EDITOR'S PICK
America Needs to Get Back to Facts
10/29/21, 2:38 PM Cancel Culture Is Not Real—At Least Not in the Way You Think | Time
https://time.com/5735403/cancel-culture-is-not-real/ 4/6
Only that’s not what’s happening. While some powerful men may not have the
status they once did, they have hardly been canceled. Louis CK admitted to
masturbating in front of female comedians. He was dropped by his agency, and
HBO and Netflix cut ties with him, but he recently sold out five shows in my
home city of Toronto. Harvey Weinstein—who has been accused of sexual
misconduct by more than 80 women (he has denied the allegations) and
charged with predatory sexual assault, a criminal sexual act and rape (he has
pleaded not guilty)—lost his job, but when he showed up at a young artists’
event in October, a comedian who called him out in her set was booed and two
women who confronted him were asked to leave. When political journalist Mark
Halperin, who denied allegations of unwanted sexual contact but acknowledged
that his “behavior was inappropriate and caused others pain,” faced pushback
over a new book, his publisher spoke to the New York Post decrying “this
guilty-until-proven-innocent cancel culture where everyone is condemned to
death or to a lifetime of unemployment based on an accusation that’s 12 years
old.” That criticism is being compared to death tells you a lot about some of the
people arguing that cancel culture has run amok.
In September, comedian Shane Gillis was fired from Saturday Night Live after
videos of him making racist jokes surfaced. Comedian Bill Burr condemned the
firing saying, “You f-cking millennials, you’re a bunch of rats, all of you,” and
“None of them care, all they want to do is get people in trouble.” But having a
job at SNL isn’t a human right. And although Gillis’ defenders have fretted
about the sanctity of free speech in comedy, the audience of a comedic TV show
should get to speak out about whether they want to watch someone who has
espoused this type of humor. That’s actually the marketplace at work. Why
should Gillis be able to utter racist things but those affected by hate speech
shut their mouths? Gillis is still a touring comedian. He will be fine.
Although use of the term spiked this year, the idea of cancel culture has been
bubbling for a while. In 2016, Kim Kardashian shared clips revealing that
BUILD A BETTER FUTURELIMITED TIME OFFER 1 YEAR FOR $15
SALE ENDS 11/7
SUBSCRIBE NOW
READ NEXT
Post-Dancing with the Stars, Karamo Brown Continues to Support His New 'Friend' Sean
Spicer
NEXT UP: EDITOR'S PICK
America Needs to Get Back to Facts
10/29/21, 2:38 PM Cancel Culture Is Not Real—At Least Not in the Way You Think | Time
https://time.com/5735403/cancel-culture-is-not-real/ 5/6
despite Taylor Swift’s claim that Kanye West didn’t warn her about a
provocative lyric, he actually did give her a heads-up and she thanked him.
Swift said she was “falsely painted as a liar.” But soon #TaylorSwiftIsCanceled-
was trending.
“When you say someone is canceled, it’s not a TV show. It’s a human being,”
Swift told Vogue this summer. “You’re sending mass amounts of messaging to
this person to either shut up, disappear, or it could also be perceived as, kill
yourself.” There aren’t many people who can understand what Swift went
through. To have so many people turn on you is surely upsetting. But how
exactly was she canceled? Though many people believed that this white woman
had disingenuously portrayed herself as a victim of a black bully and made
clear that they didn’t find that acceptable, Swift has remained one of the
highest-paid celebrities in the world.
The conversation reached a new level in October when Obama expressed
concern about the way people are called out on social media. “This idea of
purity and you’re never compromised and you’re always politically woke and all
that stuff, you should get over that quickly,” he said at a summit. He didn’t use
the term, but the assumption was he was condemning cancel culture.
Now I am certain Obama wasn’t talking about Louis CK in his call for us to be
less judgmental. He was pointing out that people are complicated and make
mistakes, though I’m not convinced they are being written off in the way he
thinks. It should also go without saying that Swift’s perceived offense should
not be lumped in with Weinstein’s alleged crimes. But that’s another problem
with the conversation about cancel culture. It oversimplifies. The term is used
in so many contexts that it’s rendered meaningless and precludes a nuanced
discussion of the specific harm done and how those who did it should be held
accountable.
Rather than panicking that someone might be asked to take a seat, we would all
do well to consider the people who are actually sidelined: those who lose
professional opportunities because of toxic workplaces, who spend years
dealing with trauma caused by others’ actions, who are made to feel unsafe.
BUILD A BETTER FUTURELIMITED TIME OFFER 1 YEAR FOR $15
SALE ENDS 11/7
SUBSCRIBE NOW
READ NEXT
Post-Dancing with the Stars, Karamo Brown Continues to Support His New 'Friend' Sean
Spicer
NEXT UP: EDITOR'S PICK
America Needs to Get Back to Facts
10/29/21, 2:38 PM Cancel Culture Is Not Real—At Least Not in the Way You Think | Time
https://time.com/5735403/cancel-culture-is-not-real/ 6/6
I write frequently about racism and Islamophobia and have received more
death threats, calls for my firing and racist insults than I can keep track of. But
when people who believe cancel culture is a problem speak out about its
supposed silencing effect, I know they’re not talking about those attacks. When
they throw around terms like “cancel culture” to silence me instead of
reckoning with the reasons I might find certain actions or jokes dehumanizing,
I’m led to one conclusion: they’d prefer I was powerless against my own
oppression.
MORE MUST-READ STORIES FROM TIME
Workers Are Furious. Their Unions Are Scrambling to Catch Up
What the Facebook Whistleblower Did to the Company's Stock in 6 Weeks
Photos from Migrants' Desperate Journeys to the U.S. Border
Emily Ratajkowski: How I Learned to Let Go
Afghanistan's Female Students Were Banned from Studying. Now Some Are
Finding New Ways to Learn
The 'Safe Supply' Movement Aims to Curb Drug Deaths Linked to the Opioid
Crisis
The 19 Most Underrated Movies on Netflix
By Ending Legacy Admissions, Amherst Hopes to Change the Makeup of Its
Student Body
Subscribe to TIME
CONTACT US AT LETTERS@TIME.COM.
TIME Ideas hosts the world's leading voices, providing commentary onevents in news, society, and culture. We welcome outside contributions.Opinions expressed do not necessarily re�ect the views of TIME editors.
SHARE THIS STORY
BUILD A BETTER FUTURELIMITED TIME OFFER 1 YEAR FOR $15
SALE ENDS 11/7
SUBSCRIBE NOW
READ NEXT
Post-Dancing with the Stars, Karamo Brown Continues to Support His New 'Friend' Sean
Spicer
NEXT UP: EDITOR'S PICK
America Needs to Get Back to Facts
